题目
Problem
Use proof by contradiction to prove that the curve with equation
y=2x+x3+cosx
has no stationary points.
(4)
题目中文翻译
用反证法证明方程
y=2x+x3+cosx
所表示的曲线没有驻点。
(4)
解答
解法一
思路
展开
按反证法,先假设曲线存在驻点,因此在某个实数 x 处导数为 0。求导并整理后,会得到 sinx=3x2+2;但右边至少为 2,与正弦函数的值域矛盾。
答题过程
展开
Assume, for a contradiction, that the curve has a stationary
point for some real value of x. Then
dxdy=0.
Differentiating,
dxdy=2+3x2−sinx.
Therefore, at the assumed stationary point,
2+3x2−sinx=sinx=03x2+2.
However, x2≥0, so
3x2+2≥2,
whereas sinx≤1 for every real x. This is a
contradiction.
Hence the original assumption is false, and the curve has
no stationary points.
也可以直接给导数设下界;仍使用上面“存在驻点”的反证假设。因为 3x2≥0 且 sinx≤1,
2+3x2−sinx≥2+0−1=1.
At the assumed stationary point, this contradicts dxdy=0. Hence there are no stationary points.