Skip to content
CalcGospel 國際數學圖譜
返回

S2 2022 Jan Q5

A Level / Edexcel / S2

IAL 2022 Jan Paper · Question 5

题目

Problem

Applicants for a pilot training programme with a passenger airline are screened for colour blindness. Past records show that the proportion of applicants identified as colour blind is 0.045

(a) Write down a suitable model for the distribution of the number of applicants identified as colour blind from a total of nn applicants.

(1)

(b) State one assumption necessary for this distribution to be a suitable model of this situation.

(1)

(c) Using a suitable approximation, find the probability that exactly 5 out of 120 applicants are identified as colour blind.

(3)

(d) Explain why the approximation that you used in part (c) is appropriate.

(2)

Jaymini claims that 75% of all applicants for this training programme go on to become pilots.

From a random sample of 96 applicants for this training programme 67 go on to become pilots.

(e) Using a suitable approximation, test Jaymini’s claim at the 5% level of significance.

State your hypotheses clearly.

(7)

(Total for Question 5 is 14 marks)

题目中文翻译

一项面向客运航空公司的飞行员培训项目会筛查申请者的色盲情况。以往记录显示,被识别为色盲的申请者比例为 0.045。

(a) 写出一个合适的模型,用于表示在总共 nn 名申请者中,被识别为色盲的人数分布。

(1)

(b) 说明使该分布适合此情境的一个必要假设。

(1)

(c) 使用适当的近似方法,求在 120 名申请者中恰好 5 人被识别为色盲的概率。

(3)

(d) 解释为什么 (c) 中使用的近似是适当的。

(2)

Jaymini 声称该培训项目的所有申请者中有 75% 最终会成为飞行员。

从该培训项目的申请者中随机抽取 96 人,其中 67 人最终成为飞行员。

(e) 使用适当的近似方法,在 5% 显著性水平下检验 Jaymini 的主张。

清楚陈述你的假设。

(7)

(第 5 题共 14 分)

解答

(a)

解法一

思路

展开

每名申请者只有“被识别为色盲”或“未被识别为色盲”两种结果,概率固定为 0.0450.045,因此人数适合用二项分布建模。

答题过程

展开

Let XX be the number of applicants identified as colour blind. A suitable model is

X∼B⁡(n,0.045).\boxed{X\sim\operatorname{B}(n,0.045)}.

(b)

解法一

思路

展开

二项模型需要各次试验独立且成功概率不变。结合题目情境,可说明不同申请者的色盲识别结果相互独立,或该比例随时间保持不变。

答题过程

展开

The applicants’ colour-blindness outcomes are independent.

(c)

解法一

思路

展开

原分布为 B⁡(120,0.045)\operatorname{B}(120,0.045)。由于 nn 大而 pp 很小,用参数 λ=np=5.4\lambda=np=5.4 的泊松分布近似,再计算恰好 5 人的单点概率。

答题过程

展开

Let XX be the number identified as colour blind. Then

X∼B⁡(120,0.045).X\sim\operatorname{B}(120,0.045).

Using the Poisson approximation,

X≈ Po⁡(120×0.045)= Po⁡(5.4).\begin{align*} X\approx&\,\operatorname{Po}(120\times0.045)\\[2mm] =&\,\operatorname{Po}(5.4). \end{align*}

Therefore, to 3 significant figures,

 P(X=5)= e−5.4(5.4)55!= 0.172821…= 0.173.\begin{align*} &\,P(X=5)\\[2mm] =&\,\frac{\mathrm{e}^{-5.4}(5.4)^5}{5!}\\[2mm] =&\,0.172821\ldots\\[2mm] =&\,\boxed{0.173}. \end{align*}

(d)

解法一

思路

展开

泊松分布近似二项分布的适用条件是试验次数较大、单次成功概率较小。本题 n=120n=120 较大而 p=0.045p=0.045 很小,符合条件。

答题过程

展开

The approximation is appropriate because the binomial distribution has a large value of nn and a very small value of pp:

n=120,p=0.045.n=120,\qquad p=0.045.

(e)

解法一

思路

展开

令 pp 为申请者最终成为飞行员的概率。主张是 p=0.75p=0.75,而检验是否“不同于”该比例,所以采用双侧检验。样本量足够大,可用正态分布近似二项分布,并对观测值 67 使用连续性修正 67.567.5。双侧 5% 检验的单尾临界概率是 0.0250.025。

答题过程

展开

Let pp be the probability that an applicant goes on to become a pilot.

H0: p=0.75,H1: p≠0.75.\begin{align*} H_0:&\,p=0.75,\\[2mm] H_1:&\,p\ne0.75. \end{align*}

Under H0H_0, if XX is the number who become pilots, then

X∼B⁡(96,0.75).X\sim\operatorname{B}(96,0.75).

The mean and variance are

 E(X)= 96(0.75)=72, Var⁡(X)= 96(0.75)(0.25)=18.\begin{align*} &\,E(X)\\[2mm] =&\,96(0.75)=72,\\[2mm] &\,\operatorname{Var}(X)\\[2mm] =&\,96(0.75)(0.25)=18. \end{align*}

Use Y∼N⁡(72,18)Y\sim\operatorname{N}(72,18) to approximate XX, and let Z∼N⁡(0,1)Z\sim\operatorname{N}(0,1). With a continuity correction,

 P(X⩽67)≈ P(Y<67.5)= P(Z<67.5−7218)= P(Z<−1.06066…)= 0.144422…\begin{align*} &\,P(X\leqslant67)\\[2mm] \approx&\,P(Y<67.5)\\[2mm] =&\,P\Big( Z<\frac{67.5-72}{\sqrt{18}} \Big)\\[2mm] =&\,P(Z<-1.06066\ldots)\\[2mm] =&\,0.144422\ldots \end{align*}

The tail probability is 0.1440.144 to 3 significant figures. Since this is a two-tailed test,

0.144>0.025.0.144>0.025.

Therefore, we do not reject H0H_0. There is insufficient evidence at the 5% significance level against Jaymini’s claim that 75% of applicants go on to become pilots.

解法二

思路

展开

也可以考察等价事件“未成为飞行员”。此时零假设比例为 0.250.25,样本中未成为飞行员的有 96−67=2996-67=29 人;使用连续性修正 28.528.5 计算右尾概率,结论应与解法一完全一致。

答题过程

展开

Let qq be the probability that an applicant does not go on to become a pilot.

H0: q=0.25,H1: q≠0.25.\begin{align*} H_0:&\,q=0.25,\\[2mm] H_1:&\,q\ne0.25. \end{align*}

There are 96−67=2996-67=29 applicants in the sample who did not become pilots. Under H0H_0,

W∼B⁡(96,0.25).W\sim\operatorname{B}(96,0.25).

Use V∼N⁡(24,18)V\sim\operatorname{N}(24,18) to approximate WW, and let Z∼N⁡(0,1)Z\sim\operatorname{N}(0,1). Using a continuity correction,

 P(W⩾29)≈ P(V>28.5)= P(Z>28.5−2418)= P(Z>1.06066…)= 0.144422…\begin{align*} &\,P(W\geqslant29)\\[2mm] \approx&\,P(V>28.5)\\[2mm] =&\,P\Big( Z>\frac{28.5-24}{\sqrt{18}} \Big)\\[2mm] =&\,P(Z>1.06066\ldots)\\[2mm] =&\,0.144422\ldots \end{align*}

Again, the tail probability rounds to 0.1440.144, and 0.144>0.0250.144>0.025, so we do not reject H0H_0. There is insufficient evidence at the 5% significance level against Jaymini’s claim.

解法三

思路

展开

不必查尾概率,也可以把标准化后的观测值与双侧检验的临界值比较。5% 双侧检验使用正态临界值 ±1.96\pm1.96;若要把临界域写回成为飞行员的人数,也要在两端分别使用连续性修正。

答题过程

展开

Let pp be the probability that an applicant goes on to become a pilot. Test

H0: p=0.75,H1: p≠0.75.\begin{align*} H_0:&\,p=0.75,\\[2mm] H_1:&\,p\ne0.75. \end{align*}

Under H0H_0, X∼B⁡(96,0.75)X\sim\operatorname{B}(96,0.75), approximated by Y∼N⁡(72,18)Y\sim\operatorname{N}(72,18). For a two-tailed 5% test, the standard normal critical values are ±1.96\pm1.96.

For the observed value X=67X=67, the continuity-corrected standardised value is

z= 67.5−7218= −1.06066…\begin{align*} z=&\,\frac{67.5-72}{\sqrt{18}}\\[2mm] =&\,-1.06066\ldots \end{align*}

This lies between −1.96-1.96 and 1.961.96, so it is not significant.

Equivalently, using continuity corrections, the lower rejection boundary satisfies

x+0.5−7218< −1.96,x< 63.1844…\begin{align*} \frac{x+0.5-72}{\sqrt{18}}<&\,-1.96,\\[2mm] x<&\,63.1844\ldots \end{align*}

and the upper rejection boundary satisfies

x−0.5−7218> 1.96,x> 80.8155…\begin{align*} \frac{x-0.5-72}{\sqrt{18}}>&\,1.96,\\[2mm] x>&\,80.8155\ldots \end{align*}

Since XX is integer-valued, the approximate critical region is

X⩽63orX⩾81.\boxed{X\leqslant63\quad\text{or}\quad X\geqslant81}.

The observed value 6767 is not in this region. We do not reject H0H_0: there is insufficient evidence at the 5% significance level against Jaymini’s claim that 75% of applicants go on to become pilots.